What Our Customers Say

“We have been with Talladega Insurance ever since we started the business 25 years ago. The relationship has since improved over time due to the personal investment on behalf of the entire staff. They’ve taken the time to come to New York to visit our job sites they insure and continue to provide comprehensive value at a fair price. In general, I am very pleased with the diversity of options for coverages available—from homeowners to boat insurance and even sophisticated coverages for a variety of construction projects. Talladega Insurance understands the nature of our business, and have helped us be more competitive in our respective marketplace. Not only that, they truly care about their customers, so much so that we have other policies with Talladega Insurance outside of the business.”

John Allen – Allen Architectural Metals

“They always respond to me in a very timely manner even on the weekends and late at night.  Great Customer service.”

Mark Burr – Synaflex Rubber Products Company, Inc.

“I’ve been with Talladega insurance since 1978 after signing on with Boyd’s father, Bill McGehee. Even though I am in Anniston and not Talladega, Boyd and his team have made themselves available to handle my insurance needs as they arise. The team at Talladega Insurance goes out of their way to try and help whenever possible. For instance, I once had hail damage to my roof, so I called Talladega Insurance. Boyd himself came to my house on a Saturday, climbed onto my roof (despite his fear of heights, sorry Boyd!), and served as my adjuster to assess the damages. This really speaks to the service I get with Talladega Insurance—they go a step further to take care of their customers. I’ve always said that insurance is only as good as the one representing you. With Talladega Insurance on my team, I’ve had all my insurance needs handled hassle-free. I recommend Talladega to my friends and family because I have had multiple policies with them for more than 40 years and have not thought about switching once!”

Rick Dawson

“When we needed liability insurance at our company, all it took was one call to Talladega insurance and the process was on! They answered our phone call immediately, and have since been very timely in their responses. The attention to detail that Talladega Insurance shows my business is incredible. Boyd and the team often call to follow up—they are true customer & client advocates. The Talladega Insurance team has given us comfort, confidence and together, we’ve built a longstanding, trusting relationship. They are a knowledgeable team and very transparent when presenting insurance options. In fact, my professional experience has led to checking with them on our home and automotive insurance—they have it all! If I were to describe Talladega Insurance in one sentence, it would be: “They are a complete package and I would confidently choose them over anyone else.””

Sai Mudiam – Metal Samples

“I’ve known the McGehees for a while and can appreciate how the agency is run like a family business. While I know I am not a big commercial client of theirs, they have treated me as important as a huge company with a warehouse full of goods they’re insuring. Boyd and the whole team go out of their way to go above and beyond on everything related to my personal insurance needs, and they always respond quickly. The personal touch that Talladega Insurance has really set them apart from everyone else.”

Thomas “Brian” Hoven

“Boyd is a great guy—I actually switched from my old provider to Talladega Insurance in 2005 and have been with them ever since. As a small business owner, it’s tough to switch insurance carriers—especially because I take the time and effort to get to know my business partners on a personal level. However, Boyd and the team were persistent in demonstrating that not only is Talladega Insurance the better option for my business, they genuinely have my best interest at heart. Boyd and the Talladega Insurance team are thoughtful, caring, and kind individuals. When a storm happened, Boyd personally reached out to me shortly thereafter to ensure my properties were damage-free—without me having to call first. Another instance that proved Talladega was the best around was when a neighbor’s tree fell on my business. Boyd and the team were there, on-site, every step of the way and worked closely with the adjuster to ensure that all aspects of the damage were covered—lost revenue, property damage, you name it. After nearly 15 years of excellent service from Talladega Insurance, I can confidently say they are true insurance experts who actually care about their customers on a personal level.”

Tim Burt